Split Happens

by Robert Earl Houston

This morning when I rose, thankful to God to see another day, I had an announcement in my e-mail concerning the organization of a new group that was forming.  It is the third such notice I’ve received in the past three weeks and unfortunately, split happens.

When I began in ministry in the 1970s, there were just (for Baptists) three major baptist conventions – the National Baptist Convention, USA., Inc. (NBCUSA), the National Baptist Convention of America (called “The Boyd Convention” or NBCA) and the Progressive National Baptist Convention, Incorporated (PNBC). Each convention was distinctive – the NBCUSA was the largest and numerically a powerhouse with members throughout the nation, especially strong in the east and north. The NBCA was strong in the south and was making strides in missions and evangelism.  The PNBC was “the thinking man’s convention” where many of the baptist educators and social crusaders made their denominational home.

Churches and Pastors identified rapidly with one of the three. NBCUSA and NBCA met the first week of September, religiously and PNBC met in August, although there was a sizeable percentage that were “dually aligned” with PNBC and one of the other two conventions. Convention halls were packed. Schools were benefitted (although in retrospect it wasn’t strong as it should have been). Properties were purchased or developed in Florida, Louisiana, Texas, and other parts of the country.

However, today there is a plethora of “national bodies” or fellowships or partnerships or ecclesiastical groups that have been borne out of conflict, burden, personal vendettas, election fall outs – and the end result is that we are in a time of where conventions increasingly no longer matter, enthusiasm for said conventions is waning and it’s becoming a game of political leapfrog (hopping from one group to the next) for a generation of preachers – which leads to the next generation of pastors and preachers rebuking all of it because of all the disunity.

State bodies are not exempt. District or City bodies are not exempt. It is a spirit of division that has taken hold in the black baptist community and if you tick off the wrong person, a “reformation” will be formed with cassocks and titular hats to replace cooperation, trust and team building.

When NBCA split in 1988-1989, I had just been called to my first church in Portland, Oregon and I remember the pain of not being able to see my friends that I “grew up with” in the conventions since my teenage years. It was an ugly, needless split and the division lines were not blurred, they were sharp. I remember saying to my pastor “why does the convention have to split?” He simply said, “split happens.”  In those two words, they were both analytical and prophetic.

What can stop the hemorrhaging?  I believe three things:

a.  It’s going to take a meeting of the minds and some acceptance of either other’s differences.  To tell the truth, we all complained, rightly so, about the divisiveness of the Tea Party, but they may have gotten some of their training from watching how we as baptists operate. We need common goals – saving Bishop College should have been the clarion call that kept three bodies together. We missed a golden moment.

b.  A Moses. The Black Baptist Church needs a Moses. Someone who can, by the strength of the Lord and a strong personality, to pull us together. The patron saints of the Church are resting in the couch of nature’s night. Who will be the next generation of leaders that want to see Pastors and Churches come together as a tool for good and social justice, instead of being pacified with a Conference that meets in a Super 8 Hotel conference room that holds 50 people and declaring “we’re worldwide.”

c.  It’s going to take some failure. Some of these groups, honestly need to fail. There needs to be some serious assessment and then foreclosure of some of these groups who have started out so that the Baptist Church can come home. Is being a Bishop worth tearing up a group that was feeding the hungry?  Is being an Adjutant to the Ninth Presiding Elder of a 40 church “International and World Wide” fellowship worth destroying years of fellowship on the local level?

I am 53. Most of my years are now behind me and I’m starting to feel like Dr. Gardner Taylor used to feel. Dr. Taylor had the desire to see all the of the Baptist Conventions meet jointly one time before his death (thank God it did happen and Dr. Taylor is still alive).  My desire is greater, I don’t want us just to come together. I want us to stay together, to break a spiritual curse.

3 responses

  1. I believe that one of the most universal of all of our proclivites as African-American people is our inability to either unite or to stay united. This mindset has unfortunatey seeped into the Black Baptist Church as well as other Black Church organizations. It’s as though from a psycho-emotional point of view that it is the psychological default of our people. Would somebody say “Willie Lynch conditioning” please? Very few organizations of African-American origination have survived this powerfully destabilizing and disentergrating mentality. The real shame of it all is that we can’t even (or won’t) see the truth of it. Great post Pastor Houston. I appreciate your passion and convicition.

  2. Pastor Terry M. Saturday | Reply

    Pastor! I am new subcriber to the Wire a pastor for more then 25 years, not currently with a local congregation, but working on my dissertation project dealing with some of the very subjects you have so approproately touched on. My dissertation is dealing with pastoral care and calling. The questionaire I need filled out by pastors from each of the convention you spoke about. I have tried contacting the secretaries of these convention with on response from either. My question to you is can you give me the information needed to either email or mail out a questionare to these pastors concerning their call into pastorship?

  3. Praise the Lord! Well said and long overdue, you took a stand, spoke the truth. It’s no wonder why the black churches are in limbo, the leader don’t want to nor know how to follow. No matter how knowledgable one is are think they maybe, a lack of unity make one detached. I offer think of the geese, these bird fly in a v shape with one nose of the V all others spreader out- if you watch them fly they all can see what ahead of them- as they follow the nose of the V geese, they all learn how to lead by watching the lead geese, what interesting about the geese each of them becomes the leader, each time the lead geese fall, the next on moves up, the pack of geese following don’t fuss and fight they just follow, because it’s the destination that the geese are looking for, through the journey each fly the wing geese of the V, each will become the lead geese, the patience in waiting, the will to learn, the obedience to follow. Makes me wonder if we can’t follow how can we grow, how can we know, how can we reach the masses. Joshua followed and obeyed the leadership of Moses and was given the blessing mission to take his lead, why because he listen, he helped, he watched, he obeyed the one that was called to lead at that time Moses… My God help us your people to get focus on you, stop thinking more of ourselves than we should, humble ourselves before you, and accept the mission, you have given the pastors. In Jesus name Amen.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


by Pastor Robert Earl Houston

H.B. Charles Jr.

About life, preaching, church, books, and other stuff.

%d bloggers like this: